Here’s a bold claim: Devin Williams could be the missing piece the San Francisco Giants need to dominate their bullpen. But here’s where it gets controversial—despite a less-than-stellar 2025 season, ESPN’s Jeff Passan insists Williams is the ‘perfect’ addition for the Giants. Why? Let’s dive in.
As the General Managers Meetings kick off in Las Vegas, the MLB offseason buzz is in full swing. While no blockbuster free agent signings have dropped yet, the rumor mill is churning. Passan’s take on Williams has sparked debate, especially after the reliever’s rocky 2025 campaign with the New York Yankees, where he posted a career-high 4.79 ERA in 67 appearances. And this is the part most people miss—Passan argues that Williams’ struggles don’t tell the full story.
In a recent column, Passan highlights the Giants’ bullpen woes, noting that Randy Rodriguez’s Tommy John surgery and Ryan Walker’s inconsistent closer performance have left a void. ‘Williams’ stuff didn’t decline,’ Passan writes. ‘His underlying metrics still scream elite, even if the results didn’t show it last season.’ Bold statement? Absolutely. But Passan’s logic isn’t without merit.
Williams’ changeup remains one of the deadliest in the league—a pitch that helped him secure 36 saves in 40 opportunities during his standout 2023 season with the Milwaukee Brewers. Pair that with the Giants’ deep pockets and the allure of pitching in one of baseball’s most pitcher-friendly parks, and you’ve got a compelling case.
Here’s the kicker: San Francisco isn’t just a desirable destination for free agents; it’s a place where Williams could thrive. As Passan puts it, ‘The Giants’ rotation and bullpen are in flux, and Williams could be the stabilizing force they need.’ But is this enough to justify calling him the ‘perfect’ fit? That’s where opinions diverge.
Critics might argue that Williams’ recent performance doesn’t warrant such high praise, while others see his potential as a game-changer. What do you think? Is Devin Williams the Giants’ missing link, or is Passan overhyping a reliever past his prime? Let’s hear your take in the comments—this debate is far from over.
